Apple

The iPad Pro needs a pro version of iOS; here’s why

Posted on January 9th, 2019 by

iPad Pro Needs an iOS ProApple's new iPad Pro is an amazing tablet, but as our review points out, it comes at a price. Apple has priced this device at close to the cost of a laptop—aka a "real computer"—which means that for most people, buying an iPad Pro means making a commitment to using it as their main computing device.

But the iPad Pro runs iOS, the same operating system that runs on the iPhone. While Apple says, "And it works like your iPhone, so it’s familiar to use," this isn't really a good thing. Some people may be able to replace their laptop with an iPad Pro, but for the iPad Pro to really serve as a computer, it needs a pro version of iOS.

Limitations of iOS

iOS was designed for the iPhone, and, while the iPad version has evolved a bit, its limitations are obvious. This starts with the nearly comical image of icons on the home screen. This display is the same on all iPads, from the petite iPad mini to the largest model, roughly twice its size. Even the 12.9" version only offers four icons horizontally in portrait mode, and five in landscape. On the big iPad Pro, the wasted space is most apparent. Many people would like to have more icons visible, rather than stuffing them in folders, but Apple doesn't seem to want to make icon organization more flexible.

This scaling is apparent across iOS. Apps display larger or smaller according to the screen size, but offer few additional controls or features with larger displays.

iOS still doesn't have real multi-tasking. It's gotten better with split-screen mode on the iPad, though using this feature is confusing, and depends on gestures, so many people will never discover it. In addition, with the newest iPad Pro models, which feature Face ID and no home button, the gestures are different from the previous iPads, so any gestures that users may have discovered on previous models will need to be re-learned. This is especially problematic if someone is using the newest iPad along with an older device.

Working with files

macOS ZIP file attachment iconA lot of "real work" on computers involves files, but iOS was designed to keep files hidden, for the most part. Apple has made progress in recent versions of iOS, acceding to the demands of users who want to work with files, but this file management isn't fully functional. What happens if you need to extract files from a ZIP archive? iOS doesn't help you, so you need to download some third-party apps that will work with these archives. The fact that Apple ignores this—and forces users to seek out third-party solutions—trivializes how common such files are, and makes it harder to work with files.

File management on iOS is clunky and complicated, and depends on the cloud, so whenever you don't have Internet access, you are hobbled when you need to move files around.

Input devices

Apple's new Pencil has certainly improved the way you interact with the device. You can sketch and draw with the pencil, mark up documents, and use it to select and edit text, though text selection—long one of the weakest areas of iOS—is still more complicated than the same process on a computer. If your work involves editing text, then the iPad can be frustrating.
Everything You Can Do with the Apple Pencil
While you can use an external keyboard—either Apple's combination keyboard-case, or any Bluetooth keyboard—you still can't connect a mouse or trackpad to the iPad. So if you do use a keyboard, you'll be raising your arms a lot to touch the screen. This can lead to pain in the shoulders, and potential repetitive stress injury. (Back in 2010, Steve Jobs said that "Touchscreen on the display is ergonomically terrible for longer interactions.") And Apple's keyboard-case only offers two angles, so it won't always be in an ergonomically ideal position.

iOS does offer keyboard shortcuts when you have an external keyboard connected, but if you type on the iPad's display itself, you have limited options in controlling the apps you work with.

Undo

iOS Undo icon (Anticlockwise Gapped Circle Arrow from Font Awesome by Dave Gandy)If there's one failure of iOS it's the way you undo an operation. You physically shake a device to undo the last thing you did. Most users only discover this when they drop their device, and see a dialog asking them to confirm their undo.

As Daring Fireball points out, there is an undo button on the virtual keyboard in iOS 12 on iPads, but it only affects text; you can press Command-Z if you are using an external keyboard; and some apps, such as graphics or photo editing tools, have adopted a counter-clockwise circular arrow button ⟲ as an undo trigger. But this process—one of the most important on any computing device—remains a kludge.

iOS 12 iPad keyboard Undo button iconThe text undo button, as it appears on iPad's virtual keyboard in iOS 12.

And the cost

Apple is trying to sell people on the idea that the iPad Pro can replace a computer. As I've explained above, this isn't entirely true, though it's fair to say that for many users, the iPad Pro will do what they need.

However, this comes at a cost. It's not just the price of the iPad itself—$799 or $999, according to its size—but also the accessories that you need to be able to use it fully. Apple's Smart Keyboard Folio—a combination input device and case—costs $179 or $199, and the Pencil costs $129 (and isn't compatible with older iPads). That's $1,107 or $1,327 to get the full package. The new 13" retina MacBook Air starts at $1,199.

If you just want standard protection without the physical keyboard, you can save $100 and buy Apple's Smart Folio (the new version of the Smart Cover) for $79 or $99—which is still 10% of the cost of the iPad Pro itself.

The verdict

There's no denying that the new iPad Pro is a fine device. I tried out the 12.9" model, and it's responsive, and easy to use—notably because of Face ID—but it's heavy, and above all, expensive.

If Apple were to give it an operating system that matches its aspirations, the iPad Pro could replace a computer for many more users than it does now. But as it stands, the iPad Pro's software hobbles its amazing build and internals. It's time for Apple to make a pro version of iOS for those people who really want to replace computers with tablets.

What else should Apple do to rethink and redesign iOS for iPads? Should there be an iOS "pro edition"? Let us know your thoughts in the comments!

About Kirk McElhearn

Kirk McElhearn writes about Macs, iPods, iTunes, books, music and more on his blog Kirkville. He is co-host of the Intego Mac Podcast and PhotoActive, and a regular contributor to The Mac Security Blog, TidBITS, and several other websites and publications. Kirk has written more than twenty books, including Take Control books about iTunes, LaunchBar, and Scrivener. Follow him on Twitter at @mcelhearn. View all posts by Kirk McElhearn →
  • JimBoulter

    I acquired a new MacBook Pro a few months back, and was so happy to finally have a new “work” machine. I tried with the iPad Pro, but I now refer to it as my consumption device rather than my work device. For consumption, while it is great, it is terribly expensive. But I’ve gotten more work done in the last few months than the prior 3 years with my iPad Pro. It truly doesn’t measure up.

    • CF

      I’m sorry, what? Do you mean you got more work done with your new MacBook Pro, or iPad Pro? Did you write it wrong? And also, why is it that a new MacBook (or iPad) would get you to do so much more work? What did you have before?

  • CreekGeek

    What do you mean by “you need a touchscreen”? It’s an iPad, the entire device is a touchscreen.

    And unfortunately, there are no other competing accessories to replace the two mentioned by the writer, made by apple. Your $18 dollar case doesn’t count. The author doesn’t include it as necessary as a case, but as a keyboard, and for the functions it adds. If you don’t own apple’s keyboard case, you should check one out. You’ll see that the case has access to dedicated ports on the iPad that come in touch as the magnets of the “case” snap into place. No Bluetooth connection issues, alboslutelh no lag. It works instantly. And it adds keyboard shortcuts along with extra functionality to the iPad, all Keith in a fairly reasonably thin “cover”.

    The Apple Pencil is also only sold by apple and with no real competition. The new Apple Pencil, much like the one before it, only work with the latest iteration of iPad pro’s. It’s also fairly expensive for a stylus, especially for a device easily dropped or lost (drop one in water as I have and it’s the fastest way to lose $100+…)

    Both those accessories are unique because they harness built in functionality *of the iPad* itself, with dedicated tech activated only for them. The iPad Pro scans faster and differently when it senses an Apple Pencil, much like the keyboard “cover” has its own dedicated communication ports with the iPad, and offer functionality built in the OS only available with a keyboard. The point here is that these devices are designed together with the iPad Pro, and offer ease of access, efficiently and performance that can’t be matched by a competitor, who say, can’t make the iPad work differently or order iOS to react faster for its styluses, or have access to its proprietary ports. Which means if you want that functionality to have the full potential of your new iPad realized, you’ll need to buy those accessories. And they’re from apple, and only available for those prices, no amount of “smart shopper” wisdom is going to help you with that. And for a tablet, a category that starts priced at $30 from amazon, the new iPad Pro is really, really expensive, and still very limited by its OS, considering its proximity in price to a full computer.

  • Toby Bridson

    All 100% true observations of the limitations of iOS. iPad Pro is clearly a high performance sports car, yet has an OS with training wheels and ribbons on the handlebars. My suspicion is there will be a professional evolution of iOS for iPad hopefully iOS 13. It’s blindingly clear that a proper file management and a truely manipulatable UI is essential. Something right in the niche between iOS and OSX which can make iPad Pro an absolute replacement for my daily carry… iPad OS anyone? Currently it’s not possible to create content and manage files without moving back to a more capable device to finish the job. Tim Cook, if you are reading this please take notice. When people stop telling you what you’re doing wrong, that’s a bad place to be!… I live in hope.

  • phillip bakalchuk

    APPLE, STOP BEING SUCH CONTROL FREAKS…YOU ARE AN AMAZINGLY BRILLIANT COMPANY…YOU ARE PURPOSEFULLY SABOTAGING YOUR DEVICE TO FORCE YOUR CUSTOMERS TO BUY MORE INDIVIDUAL DEVICES, RATHER THAN FEWER MORE FLEXIBLE DEVICES. ALLOW USERS TO STORE AND MOVE FILES WHEREVER THEY WANT! ALLOW A NATURAL WORK FLOW WITH MOUSE/TRACKPAD!

    the only reasons Apple purposely hobbles the iPad pro with a phone operating system are the following

    (1) purity of concept: apple believes all mobile devices should have a common operating system. problem is that if you want to use the iPad pro as a computer it can’t be limited that way. no mouse? no trackpad? no keyboard with an escape key? really? the other real reason is that when there is no more innovation to be had, all apple can think of is the usual: faster, slimmer, better screen and camera…that is NOT innovation.

    (2) organization and control freaks: apple has a thing against organizing and storing things. no file manage? really? the files app sucks…you still can’t store locally on the device unless it’s in an apple-supported application…that’s completely illogical. people don’t store a single project’s multiple file types in different folders….especially not in application folders? really? the fact that when dropping and dragging you have to drag a file into folders before you open the destination folder…it only opens when you’re in it…frequently you “drop” the file accidentally, or notice it’s not the right folder, and there is no way to go back? really? there is no undo in the files app! sometimes you have to hover over the destination folder for a couple of seconds until it opens…by the way, the file manger on Mac is similar…unless you open dual windows there is no way to drag and drop without the aforementioned. why can’t i download a video from a 3rd party on the internet? if i could, there would be no place to put it….you can’t even save to a desktop. why not? the desktop has ridiculously large icons with tons of empty space? why not let the user determine how many apps show up on the screen? this is just total control freak stuff….controls how you file, store, etc.

    (2) the other is that apple doesn’t want to cannibalize their other products….the more it works like a computer the less you need both. many apple fans have both, and that would cut into sales. BUT APPLE, you can’t sacrifice a company’s innovation for excellence and innovation just to keep product lines in their own lanes.

  • シルバヌス マルコム

    The usual bullcrap and I am typing this on my new ipad Pro which I have reduced to a facebook reading and music listening device, bought this coz I hate my Mac Book pro with it’s noisy keyboard and I am back to square one, using the same noisy MacBook I dread and this well at least it allowed me to write this post

  • panda1264

    should Apple do a rethink and redesign iOS for iPads?..YES, it Should be an iOS “pro edition”?