Apple + Software & Apps

Windows XP’s Death: Good Time to Switch to Apple?

Posted on April 14th, 2014 by

Windows XP logo superimposed by Apple logoAs you've probably heard by now, Windows XP will no longer receive new security updates from Microsoft. This past Tuesday was the final day of support for the nearly 13-year-old operating system, which means that XP will become increasingly unsafe to use online as unpatched vulnerabilities begin to be exploited in the wild.

Sure, there are various things XP users can do to help avoid infection, such as using a non-administrator account (PDF), keeping antivirus software up to date, keeping up with non-Microsoft patches available for XP (e.g. Adobe Reader, Flash Player, Java, etc.), setting Google Chrome or Mozilla Firefox as the default browser (since XP's Internet Explorer 8 will no longer be updated), and avoiding the Internet as much as possible or at least being particularly cautious about how you use it (e.g. avoid visiting unfamiliar sites, opening e-mails from unknown senders, etc.). But one of the first lines of defense on any computer is keeping the operating system patched, and that's no longer an option with Windows XP. (Unless you've got millions of dollars to throw at Microsoft for private support, that is.)

Windows 8.1?Microsoft, of course, wants you to purchase an upgrade to Windows 8.1, or purchase a new computer with Windows 8.1 preinstalled.

But for a significant number of those who are still using Windows XP, neither of those options is very appealing.

The average user simply doesn't have the time, patience, or expertise to manually back up all their files and programs, reformat their hard drive, and reinstall everything from scratch (which is required for an upgrade, since you can't jump directly from XP to 8.1).

For many users, the monetary costs of upgrading are also a concern. Many will balk at paying a whopping $120 to $200 (or the slightly more reasonable $70 for students; all prices are in U.S. dollars) for Windows 8.1—which some people view as another Vista, as it features radical changes that don't appeal to everyone (the lack of a Start menu, the new default Start screen interface with "tiles", the two separate versions of Internet Explorer that behave differently, etc.).

Users who lack the time or the technical skill required to reformat and reinstall Windows on their own could be stuck paying for not only Windows 8.1 itself, but also the labor costs of having a computer shop or local technician do the upgrade for them. (Best Buy's Geek Squad, for example, charges an additional $130 to $200 for in-store or on-site Windows installation, respectively—and that doesn't include the copy of Windows—so you could end up paying $400 if you buy Windows 8.1 Pro and then have someone install it for you.) You might also need to buy a RAM upgrade if you have a particularly old PC. And if you're going to spend that much money anyway, you'd probably be better off buying a brand new PC.

For some, refusing to switch to Windows 8.1 is a matter of principle; Microsoft is knowingly putting the world at risk by abandoning Windows XP, which is still used by 27% of the world's online computers according to the latest numbers from Net Applications.

Desktop OS Market Share, March 2014 (Net Market Share)
It's not just those 27% of computers that could be negatively impacted by Microsoft's abandonment of XP. PCs that become infected due to a lack of security updates could end up as participants in a botnet, for example. Grandma's old Windows XP tower could end up sending spam or participating in distributed denial of service (DDoS) attacks.

Although Microsoft has legitimate reasons to stop patching such an ancient (in computer years) operating system, some view the termination of Windows XP updates as little more than an excuse to profit from users who will be forced to buy an upgrade. Naturally, the perception of being victimized by a multibillion-dollar corporation isn't likely to make anyone feel very happy (except, perhaps, the corporation's shareholders).

Meanwhile, Apple's OS X and iOS operating system upgrades are free.

All recent versions of iOS have been free for all supported devices, and beginning with Mavericks, Apple has begun releasing major OS X upgrades at no cost for all supported Macs.

Since people who still use Windows XP are going to have to shell out some cash one way or another, some might reasonably use this as an opportunity to buy a Mac or an iPad for the first time.

Trashing XP for iPad
Now could be a great time for XP users to switch to Apple.

Depending on what one uses their computer for, Windows XP switchers might be happy getting a Mac mini to use with their PC's old monitor. While the Mac mini's $600 price tag ($580 for education customers) might be a bit much for someone who's already unhappy about having to replace their Windows XP PC, previous-generation Mac minis with a Core i3 or i5 processor can often be found for $450 or less on eBay (example U.S. search; check the "Show only sold listings" box to see the most recent sale prices).

But the really sweet deal might be an iPad, if an iPad will do everything the user wants to do. An iPad mini starts at $300, and Apple sells refurbished iPads for even cheaper. That price point is certainly competitive with low-cost Windows PCs, and you aren't likely to find Apple-quality hardware amongst the selection of Windows PCs at that price.

I'm not naïve enough to predict a massive global surge in iPad sales, all thanks to former Windows XP users switching in droves. But I do see the iPad as a decent alternative for many XP users who dread the idea of being forced to migrate to Windows 8.1.

And last but not least, since we're discussing Windows XP, this is as good a time as any to remind readers that if you still use Windows XP on your Mac via Boot Camp or a virtual machine, you may want to consider upgrading your Mac's copy of Windows as well.

About Joshua Long

Joshua Long (@theJoshMeister) is a renowned security researcher and writer. Josh has a master's degree in IT concentrating in Internet Security and has taken doctorate-level coursework in Business Administration and Computer and Information Security. His research has been featured by many fine publications such as CNET, CBS News, ZDNet UK, Lifehacker, CIO, Macworld, The Register, and MacTech Magazine. Look for more of Josh's security articles at security.thejoshmeister.com and follow him on Twitter and Google+. View all posts by Joshua Long →
  • Bob DeGrande

    I’m all for Windows users trying a Mac or an iPad, but I can’t see Microsoft discontinuing support for XP as a money grab. XP is older than OS X 10.2, it was long past time to drop support for it. If anything, Microsoft hasn’t moved fast enough to change their OS, that Windows 8 still has a registry really cripples it, they should have blown it up and restarted from scratch as Apple did with OS X.

    • CallMeYoDaddy

      Agreed. After Windows 8 was released, Microsoft should have just offered Windows XP users Windows 7 for free or $9.99 but either way Microsoft could have pushed harder to get far more people (with legitimate copies) to ditch Windows XP. I don’t feel Microsoft should continue supporting an ancient operating system like XP. It’s time to move along.

  • Dave Koch

    Windows 7 isn’t too bad, but Windows 8 is by far the most awful OS Microsoft ever produced. Windows 7 is way over priced, but then there are plenty of published license keys available on the Internet. Windows XP was among Microsoft’s best OS’s. If it has simply offered a $20/year up date fee, I suspect many people would have embraced that. I switched to Mac several years ago, and I am still growing into my systems as opposed the my systems becoming obsolete weeks after purchase. The only software that Microsoft produces that is worth using is Office. Since there is a great Mac version, I just use that.

Sign up For Our Newsletter

Get the latest Mac security news direct to your inbox.

{"url":"\/marketo\/json\/add-to-newsletter","data":"list_name=Blog Roadblock"}